Modified Endowment Contract (MEC): The 7-Pay Test Explained

A life insurance policy can keep its death benefit and still lose the tax treatment you expected for money taken out while you are alive.

That is the modified endowment contract problem.

A MEC is not a broken policy. It is a life insurance contract that crossed a federal funding line. The change can make withdrawals and loans taxable sooner and may add a 10% federal tax to the taxable amount.

If someone tells you to "max fund" a policy, the seven-pay test belongs in the same conversation.

What is a modified endowment contract?

Under Internal Revenue Code section 7702A, a life insurance contract is a modified endowment contract if it meets the tax definition of life insurance but fails the seven-pay test. A contract received in exchange for a MEC is generally also a MEC.

The rule was designed to separate life insurance from a contract funded too quickly for the intended tax treatment of living distributions.

MEC status mainly changes how money taken from the contract is taxed. It does not, by itself, erase the policy's death benefit. The general life-insurance death-proceeds rule and its exceptions still require a separate review.

How does the 7-pay test work?

The seven-pay test asks whether cumulative premiums paid during the first seven contract years exceed the cumulative premiums that would have paid up the policy under the statutory test.

The word cumulative matters.

You do not just compare this year's premium with a one-year cap. The insurer calculates a contract-specific seven-pay premium from the benefit, age, policy terms, assumptions required by law, and later changes. Payments are tracked against a growing cumulative limit.

The scheduled premium, guideline premium, and seven-pay premium are different numbers. Ask the carrier for the actual MEC limit before sending extra money.

A sales illustration may show a planned premium that stays under the line. That does not mean any later payment is safe. A lump sum, rider change, death-benefit change, dividend choice, or other policy action can alter the test.

A plain-English 7-pay example

Assume an insurer reports a tested limit of $10,000 per year for a simple illustration.

End of contract year | Cumulative tested limit | Cumulative premiums paid | Result at that point
1 | $10,000 | $9,000 | Under
2 | $20,000 | $18,000 | Under
3 | $30,000 | $31,000 | Over

The contract could fail in year three even though the year-three payment alone was $13,000. The comparison is cumulative.

This is teaching math only. An actual seven-pay premium must come from the insurer's contract calculation.

What changes when life insurance becomes a MEC?

For a non-MEC life insurance contract, some distributions may recover investment in the contract before gain, subject to the exact transaction and tax rules.

For a MEC, section 72 generally applies an income-first rule. Value above investment in the contract comes out before basis.

MEC status can change the tax result even when the same policy value is available. Ask for the carrier's tax basis and gain figures before taking money.

Withdrawals

A withdrawal is included in income to the extent of gain in the contract. Basis comes after that gain under the MEC ordering rule.

Policy loans and pledges

For a MEC, a loan, assignment, or pledge of contract value can be treated as an amount received. Calling it a loan does not make the tax rule disappear.

The additional 10% federal tax

Section 72(v) can add 10% of the taxable portion. Exceptions include distributions after age 59 1/2, disability under the statutory definition, and certain substantially equal periodic payments.

The added tax does not apply to the entire loan or withdrawal when only part is included in income. State tax can be different.

Can a later change restart the test?

Yes. A material change can cause the contract to be treated as a new contract for seven-pay testing. Federal law includes rules for benefit increases and other changes, with technical exceptions.

The safe move is not to decide for yourself whether a change is material.

Run the test before the change or extra premium. A verbal "you should be fine" is not a policy record.

Ask for a new written test before:

raising or reducing the death benefit;

adding or changing a rider;

paying an unscheduled lump sum;

changing a premium pattern;

using dividends to buy benefits;

exchanging the contract; or

making a large withdrawal or partial surrender.

The law also has a two-year lookback rule for certain distributions made in anticipation of a later seven-pay failure. Timing alone does not create a clean escape.

Can an accidental MEC be fixed?

Do not assume it can be undone.

Section 7702A contains a rule that can adjust premiums when an excess amount is returned with interest within 60 days after the end of the contract year. The facts, timing, policy administration, and tax reporting matter. Insurers may have correction procedures, but those procedures are not permission to overpay first and solve it later.

Contact the carrier's tax or advanced-markets unit at once. Ask what amount caused the issue, which contract year is involved, the deadline, what will be returned, and whether any tax form will be issued. A qualified tax professional should review the result.

A MEC received in an exchange generally stays a MEC. Replacing the policy is not a reliable reset button.

Questions to ask before funding near the MEC limit

Get the answers in writing:

What is the current annual and cumulative seven-pay limit?

How much premium has been counted so far?

How much room remains today?

Do automatic drafts, paid-up additions, dividends, or rider premiums count?

What policy change could restart or reduce the limit?

Will the carrier reject or refund a payment that would cause a MEC?

What happens to loans, withdrawals, surrender value, and tax reporting if it becomes a MEC?

Is the illustration showing guaranteed values, non-guaranteed values, or both?

What are the surrender charges and current in-force values?

Who is responsible for monitoring the test after the sale?

Also read how whole-life payment schedules work and how IUL illustrations can change. The MEC test is one boundary. It does not tell you whether the policy is affordable, well designed, or better than another option.

Common MEC questions

Is a modified endowment contract illegal?

No. It is a tax classification. A person may knowingly accept it, but the living-distribution tax rules should be understood first.

Does a MEC lose its death benefit?

MEC status does not by itself cancel the policy or its death benefit. Policy lapse, loans, ownership, transfer-for-value, estate, and beneficiary rules still matter.

Is every single-premium life policy a MEC?

Do not assume either answer. Many heavily funded contracts become MECs, but the insurer must apply the statutory test to the exact contract.

Are MEC loans tax-free?

That is the dangerous shortcut. Federal law can treat a MEC loan or pledge as a distribution, taxable to the extent of contract gain.

Does the seven-pay test end after seven years?

The original test period is seven contract years, but a later material change can start a new seven-year test. Other adjustments and lookback rules can also matter.

This guide is general federal tax education. Life-insurance contracts and tax facts differ. Get current carrier records and individual tax advice before funding, changing, exchanging, or taking money from a policy.

Sources

U.S. House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 26 U.S.C. 7702A. Accessed July 31, 2026.

Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 7702A. Accessed July 31, 2026.

U.S. House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, 26 U.S.C. 72. Accessed July 31, 2026.

Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 72. Accessed July 31, 2026.

Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 7702. Accessed July 31, 2026.

Cornell Legal Information Institute, 26 U.S.C. 101. Accessed July 31, 2026.

IRS, Revenue Procedure 2007-19. Accessed July 31, 2026.

IRS, Form 1099-R instructions. Accessed July 31, 2026.

National Association of Insurance Commissioners, Consumer's Guide to Life Insurance. Accessed July 31, 2026.

FINRA, Life Insurance. Accessed July 31, 2026.